CFM Insurance Team

From responsive underwriting guidance and claim assistance to detailed advertisement planning and accounting support, the CFM Team is readily equipped and available to help your agency thrive. We want each agent encounter to be positive and productive. Please look at our organized department breakdown below to quickly find who can best support your specific needs.
Matt-1

Matt Osterthun

Assistant Vice President, Sales & Marketing
800.218.2223 ext.148
Danny M

Danny Miller

Agency Development Representative
800.218.2223 ext.149
Abby

Abby Rhoads

Agency Support Coordinator
800.218.2223 ext. 302
Josh D

Josh Diehl

Senior Business Analyst
800.218.2223 ext.305
Maggie

Maggie Taylor

Business Analyst
800.218.2223 ext.430
Cindy

Cindy Tolias

Director, Mutual Integrations & Underwriting
800.218.2223 ext.116
Marty-2

Marty Wynn

Mutual Integrations Manager
800.218.2223 ext.153
Stef_166

Stefanie Belshe

Underwriting Supervisor
800.218.2223 ext.115
Diana_260

Diana Armstrong

Underwriter
800.218.2223 ext.122
Rhonda

Rhonda Evans

Underwriter
800.218.2223 ext.239
Catie_260

Catie Shippen

Underwriter
800.218.2223 ext.128
Melissa Hartwig_260

Melissa Hartwig

Underwriter
800.218.2223 ext.124
Oakley

Oakley Harris

Associate Underwriter
800.218.2223 ext.129
Mike S

Mike Schumacher

Loss Control Representative
800.218.2223 ext.171
Taylor

Taylor Borgstadt

Underwriter
800.218.2223 ext.136
Kent

Kent Peterson

Assistant Vice President, Claims
800.218.2223 ext.321
Ben_260

Ben Renno

Property Claims Manager
800.218.2223 ext.118
Brian aa

Brian Atkinson

Property Claims Adjuster
800.218.2223 ext. 164
Brian

Brian Guess

Property Claims Adjuster
800.218.2223 ext. 157
Teagan_260

Teagan Steinkuhler

Desk Adjuster
800.218.2223 ext. 138
Paul_166

Paul Williams

Auto Claims Manager
800.218.2223 ext. 298
Sally_166

Sally Sutter

Senior Claims Representative
800.218.2223 ext. 301
Dillion L

Dillon Lee

Claims Adjuster
800.218.2223 ext. 162
TammyF_Icon

Debra Brandes

Casualty Claims Adjuster
800.218.2223 ext. 181
Tiffany_260

Tiffany Jones

Director of Finance
800.218.2223 ext. 139
Jen L

Jen LeClaire

Senior Accountant
800.218.2223 ext.179
Bev_260

Bev Frerking

Accountant
800.218.2223 ext.113
Anna_260

Anna Morrison

Accountant
800.218.2223 ext.137
Brittany

Brittany Bonine

Accounting Staff Assistant
800.218.2223 ext.503
Destini-1

Destini Nave

Director of Marketing & Strat Comm
800.218.2223 ext. 405
Ben G

Ben Goodman

Marketing & Event Manager
800.218.2223 ext.303
Melissa Hoefer-1

Melissa Hoefer

Senior Graphic Designer
800.218.2223 ext.144
Morgan Nail

Morgan Nail

Senior Marketing Content Specialist
800.218.2223 ext. 106
Sheena-1

Sheena Grindstaff

Marketing Content Creator
800.218.2223 ext.166
Sam Kenney

Sam Kenney

Digital Marketing Specialist
800.218.2223 ext.152
Bill_260

Bill Corwin

Assistant Vice President, Information Technology
800.218.2223 ext.319
Pam

Pam Whalen

System Project Management Specialist
800.218.2223 ext. 167
Robin-1

Robin Chambers

System Implementation Manager
800.218.2223 ext. 121
Andrew

Andrew Power

IT Systems Associate
800.218.2223 ext. 230
Chantel_166

Chantel Huse

UAT Specialist
800.218.2223 ext. 103
Katlyn R

Katyln Rekhop

UAT Specialist
800.218.2223 ext. 114
TammyF_Icon

Dylan Rackers

IT Network & Security Specialist
800.218.2223 ext. 322
Jake B_260

Jacob Black

President, Chief Executive Officer
800.218.2223
Jen Regas

Jen Regas

Chief Financial Officer
800.218.2223
Scott F_166

Scott Forrest

General Counsel
800.218.2223
Joey2

Joey Kenney

Vice President, Underwriting & Product Development | Chief Underwriting Officer
800.218.2223
Ashley_166

Ashley Sterk

Senior Executive to the President / CEO & Board of Directors
800.218.2223 ext. 101

Our Values

Here’s to insurance that not only protects but inspires. Here’s to putting community first.

CFM_Emblem_Color

Most Trusted MO Mutual

As one of our trusted agents, you know - we didn’t become Missouri’s most trusted Mutual Insurance Company by spending aimless advertising dollars to win over customers. We aren’t known for our flashy Super Bowl ads or fancy celebrity endorsements. We don’t even have a catchy jingle – that’s just not our style. What we are known for is our devotion to bettering the communities we serve.

CFM_Emblem_Color_Favicon

Premium With A Purpose

At CFM, we believe true customer loyalty comes from a winning game plan that’s beneficial to everyone on the team - and it’s hard to lose when you’re giving back. So we’ve made it our mission to create a truly rewarding insurance experience for each and every policyholder by making sure their premium comes full circle, continuously flowing back into the places they call home.

CFM_Emblem_Color_Favicon

The CFM Circle

As a piece of the CFM circle, you're part of a tight-knit family of like-minded individuals collectively dedicated to helping every community in Missouri not only stay alive but thrive. Together, alongside you and our customers, we can advocate for the places and things that matter most by keeping your business and their premium local.